Insider’s Tip: It’s a miracle how the Vintages Catalogue is able to dredge up flattering of reviews for some of its worst selections. Unfortunately, that wasn’t the case for the best buy red of next Saturday’s Vintages release - Voyager Estate 1999 Shiraz from Western Australia’s Margaret River at only $21.55. The sweet, faintly smoky, black raspberry purée nose is followed up by complex, extracty, creamy, roasted plum and chocolate-cherry flavours that go on and on. Not only did Vintages not mention James Halliday’s rating of 94 out of 100 points, but also not a drop was presented to LCBO consultants or wine writers. You can start lining up now for the 150 cases. If you want to get the full lowdown rating all of next week’s Vintages products subscribe to Vintage Assessments today by clicking here: Subscribe Today  

Vintage Assessments Home Page

Recent Articles

Archive of National Post Articles


Sign-up Now!

Fruit Wines Squeezed out by the LCBO
© Michael Vaughan 2002
National Post Weekly Wine & Spirits Columnist
National Post • Saturday, March 30, 2002

It’s amazing how some things are always with you. As a 9-year-old, I would make a beeline to a neighbor’s house whose Easter ritual involved opening his treasured bottles of homemade wine. And they weren’t any old wines, but delicious sweet fruit wines – perfect harbingers of Spring and all the good things to come.

Unfortunately, he is no longer with us and I have lost touch with his son - my buddy ‘Eddie.” My thirst for the nectar of our local fruit, however, still remains. In spite of the LCBO’s massive growth of new stores over the past decade, finding these treasures has not become an easier task

It’s tragic that with the massive increase in Ontario fruit wines (produced by more than 30 wineries), they still are almost impossible to find. A glance at my local liquor store shelves reminds me of old Mother Hubbard’s cupboard. And when I ask the manager about this absence, his answer is that “nobody buys them.” “Well of course nobody buys them,” I reply, “you don’t sell them!”

Unfortunately, the LCBO is now more determined than ever to reduce consumer choice. Head office recently forced many store managers to arbitrarily remove 20% or more of existing selections. Instead of spreading shelf facings to show more wines, the monopoly has dictated that there shall be more facings of the same old highest selling wines. Slow movers are put on the bottom shelves, just a step closer to the door.

The LCBO suggestion that this diminishing selection represents consumer choice is pathetic. In fact, it’s simply a matter of LCBO greed – maximizing profits at the consumer’s expense. And there may well be another agenda as this policy gives a few large, well-heeled, global wine producers/distributors an iron grip on sales in this province. “It’s becoming worse than what’s happening in California grocery chains where a half dozen labels constitute 90% of sales,” bemoans one agent. “At least there, you can put your wines into the smaller private stores who care about choice.”

“The LCBO claim that it encourages competition is truly BS,” says another disillusioned wine importer. “Our company has been waiting patiently for more than two years and we are still unable to get a single case of consignment warehouse allocation space. It’s a closed shop!”

Obviously this is also a terrible problem for our local fruit wineries that cannot gain access to the market. Retail locations are desperately needed immediately. And yet the when it comes to selling wine, our provincial government seems incapable of acting quickly or doing the right thing. A year ago I complained that the LCBO Price Book didn’t have a fruit wine section and, as of today, nothing has changed.

The answer would be to immediately sanction the opening of privately owned stores dedicated to selling fruit wines complete with a sampling station. It’s done in Montreal, so why not Ontario? And what could be better than putting the comprehensive fruit wine store in St. Lawrence Market? Imagine being able to drop by today and sample delicious, locally-made fruit wines and then selecting the perfect one for your Easter dinner? 

Not only will the government be increasing profits through these sales, but these badly needed retail outlets will provide a real solution helping dozens of small Ontario businesses succeed. Of course, it will only work if bulk, imported, “Product of Canada” low-cost fruit wine blends are kept off the shelves. Space has to be reserved for the dozens of genuine artisan producers not just a few conglomerates who already own most sales.

While there is still a lot of variability from year to year, as well as some distinctly disappointing bottles, quality has improved immensely from five years ago. After recently blind tasting some 96 fruit wine submissions at the Toronto Wine & Cheese Show, 38 received awards which is a much higher proportion than for regular table wines. Press Here to see the full list of winners is available on my website).

It saddens me to report that less than half a dozen can be purchased at the LCBO. The best of show off-dry fruit wine, for instance, Hernder 2001 Rhubarb at $12.95 for a 500 ml bottle is only available at the winery. This show-stopper has terrific, sweet but refreshing, vibrant, rhubarb flavours that bring a smile to your lips - a real smile.

This lack of availability also applies to the best of show sweet fruit wine Scotch Block 2001 Cassis Black Currant at $14.95 for 500 ml. The sweet, creamy black currant flavours make for a perfect after dinner Easter dessert wine.

For cranberry lovers, the best of show was the beautifully crafted Muskoka Lakes 2000 Cranberry at $12.95, again only available at the winery. The store, which is located near Bala, reopened on March 23rd. While this wine would be sheer perfection with a juicy slice of Easter ham, Muskoka Lakes  has yet to receive approval from the AGCO (Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario) permitting them to ship the wine.  See http://www.cranberry.ca/winery2.html So if you need a bottle today, you will have to check out Vintages where the bronze medal winning Stoney Ridge 2000 Cranberry is available at $12.95 (CSPC 392191).

Seasonal favourites include the gold medal winning Archibald Winery Spiced Winter Apple at $14.95, again only at the winery. Also the very sweet, tasty Archibald Canadian Maple is one of the few wines you actually buy at you local LCBO store at $16.95 for 375 ml (CSPC 564492) 564484). It is perfect with Easter Sunday waffles or simply poured on a steaming slice of Easter ham. Search under Canadian dessert wines at the LCBO.

Of all producers, Southbrook Winery has consistently made Canada’s best. All five 2002 submissions got medals, including three golds - Southbrook Blueberry, Cassis and Framboise all $14.95 for 375 ml. While the latter is available on the LCBO general list, four medal winning wines (including the Blackberry and Framboise d’Or) are only at Vintages. Southbrook Cassis, a regular best of show contender/winner, is currently out of stock at Vintages but available at the winery. To discover which is best, check out the winery tasting bar at 1061 Major Mackenzie Drive in Maple. And make sure you taste Southbrook Framboise, which was the first Ontario wine to be carried by Harrods department stores in England.

 

Coming Up: The California Wine Fair featuring 70 wineries and 250 wines arrives at Toronto’s Fairmont Royal York on April 10th. For information call 1-800-558-2675. Also  “A Nip of Napa” in Epic Restaurant features a Stag’s Leap Winery seminar on Monday, April 8th and Far Niente Winemaker Dinner on Tuesday, April 9th. Call (416) 860-6949 for details.

 

Copyright Food & Beverage Testing Institute of Canada 2004
Prior written permission is required for any form of reproduction
 (electronic or other wise) and or quotation.
Contact Michael Vaughan at
mbv@total.net